Puppy Purchase Guide

What is a Backyard Breeder? Backyard Breeder vs Reputable Breeder

Pomeranian Headquarters

Sharing is caring!

Last Updated on 28/06/2023 by Dochlaggie. Post first published on October 28, 2021.

While it may cost you less to get a dog from a backyard breeder than from a reputable, show Pomeranian breeder, there are, sadly, very good reasons why. Those same reasons are why you should avoid backyard breeders.

Recently there has been more exposure in the media regarding puppy mills but it hasn’t covered the sad scenario of backyard breeding, despite increasing public awareness of animal cruelty.

These people are responsible for most of the overpopulation issues associated with animal shelters and forced euthanasia incidents. To really understand the issue with backyard breeding your need to understand what is a backyard breeder?

What is a Backyard Breeder?

The term “backyard breeding” refers to people who breed animals in an irresponsible manner. Backyard breeders are people who don’t do any research on the breed and just have a litter of puppies. They often buy breeding stock from other backyard breeders to keep up with the demand for their animals.

In contrast to responsible breeders, these people have little experience or knowledge with breeding dogs. They typically produce litters for sale without taking the time to make good genetic matches. Irresponsible breeding litters to make a profit off of the so-called purebred dogs that they own.

They may let these animals reproduce without knowledge or concern about genetic health issues. Their main interest is in making as much money as possible whilst spending as little as they can. They don’t care about the welfare of animals in their care and that results in poor quality specimens that deserve much better.

A backyard breeder breeds animals that often are not registered with an animal breeding association. Backyard breeders often don’t show concern for the animals’ health and may produce unhealthy offspring, which they then sell to unsuspecting buyers.

Sometimes a backyard breeder doesn’t initially set out to do harm but their bitch may have an unwanted pregnancy because they failed to have her desexed.

Sometimes they’re bred so puppies can be sold for a quick profit. “Puppy farm” or “puppy mill” are the two most commonly used terms to describe this behavior when done on a big scale.

Some breeders think they can produce good quality show dogs and rake in the big money. Other backyard breeders are under the false assumption that all dogs must produce one or more litters to feel fulfilled.

However, the most common reason a backyard breeder does it initially is with the best intentions. They have a really great, loving pet and they believe that lots of puppies will enable others to also have such a wonderful experience.

what is a backyard breeder
What is a backyard breeder?

11 Signs of a Backyard Breeder

I think it is a personal decision whether you purchase your next pup from an experienced preservation breeder or adopt one.

If you’re going to purchase a puppy from a dog breeder, here are some things that will help determine whether or not they’re responsible. If you’re looking to find a reputable breeder, these guidelines will help point out some considerations. Always use your best judgment.

  • You’re not allowed to visit the dog breeder.
  • You’re not allowed to see the pup’s parents or the other dogs.
  • The puppies can leave mom before 8 weeks of age.
  • The dog breeder does not ask about the type of home you can provide for the puppy.To a responsible breeder, the puppy is like their child and they want to ensure that it goes into an excellent home.
  • The breeder has many different breeds. Good breeders are focused on bettering their breed, but it would be impossible to focus on four or five different species.
  • Puppies are always available.
  • The dog breeder does not provide a sales contract. The contract should state that the breeder offers a health guarantee, what they expect from their buyers and what the buyer can expect from the seller.
  • The breeder doesn’t want to hear from you after they sell their puppy. Good breeders will be available to any questions and provide support for the pup’s life.
  • The breeder does not prove their dogs in the show ring prior to breeding. Proving in the show ring is a crucial tool for for temperament testing, behavourial issues as well as seting breed type.
  • The dog breeder is not active in any breed specific clubs.
  • A responsible breeder will demand to have the dog returned if you can no longer care for it.

Backyard Breeder vs Reputable Breeder

What separates backyard breeders and genuine, responsible, reputable breeders are the standards the breeder meets before even planning the litter and the care provided for the dogs and litters.

Good intentions often aren’t enough

Puppy mill owners work on the premise of high volume breeding with only minimal care and poor living conditions.

Backyard breeders are a bit different in some cases. Those who are only keen to make huge profits are virtually the same as the mill owners. Big litters, various breeds, dirty cages for homes, and poorly fed animals are the result of their lack of care.

Puppies in pet stores are usually sourced from puppy mills and backyard breeders.

There are others involved in backyard breeding who may appear harmless at first or can be hard to identify. They only breed one or two litters and house them inside so others aren’t aware of what they’re doing.

They may raise both parents and even let you see them when you meet the puppies. You’ll naturally assume they have been cared for properly as they’ll all look clean and happy.

You won’t suspect they’re backyard breeders, even though they have the best intentions and there are times when they don’t even think they’re doing anything wrong.

Backyard Breeder Type Pomeranian Puppies
Backyard Breeder Type Pomeranian Puppies

What’s Wrong With Backyard Breeding?

The first obvious fact is they don’t have the knowledge and experience that a genuine show Pomeranian breeder has when it comes to breeding their chosen breed.

The genuine show Pomeranian breeders can breed for ideal qualities and reduce any unwanted characteristics and they’ll usually have some knowledge of genetics.

They keep comprehensive files on all their dogs and puppies, often going back a few generations. Serious health concerns can be screened for.

On the other hand, a backyard Pomeranian breeder will have some knowledge of his breed and will assume everything else.

Backyard Pomeranian breeders typically simply mate their bitches to the most conveniently located and available male. Perhaps their own male or a friend’s dog, without any health screenings, research on the breeding lines, and any compatibility concerns.

The backyard Pomeranian breeder’s bitch may have a genetic predisposition towards luxating patellas or other problems he may not know about. Because of insufficient knowledge of prior generations, new owners may incur thousands of dollars in expenses to fix major health problems.

Even worse is that the new owner may have a temperamental new dog that may end up being left at a shelter or, sadly, being euthanized. Show Pomeranian breeders, on the other hand, will devote many hours to planning a litter with dogs that are true to the Pomeranian Breed Standard, have been temperament tested, proven in the show ring, and have health tested.

Pomeranian puppy from a Show Breeder versus Pet Shop or Backyard Breeder Pomeranian Puppy
Pomeranian puppy from a Show Breeder versus Pet Shop or Backyard Breeder Pomeranian Puppy

Reputable Breeders

The objective of SHOW dog breeders is to preserve dog breeds, contribute to the advancement of the breed by producing dogs that are healthy in mind and body and are as close as possible to the Breed Standard.

Animal welfare is always a number one priority with responsible breeding. These dog breeders also provide support for shelter animals.

Most genuine dog breeders will put restrictions on the puppy owner’s right to breed and will get pet puppy buyers to sign a specific contract, promising they won’t breed the puppies, thereby avoiding the creation of substandard litters. Some will give a partial refund if a buyer has a neuter/spay certificate supplied by their vet.

Many Pomeranian lovers regard breeding high-quality, healthy Poms as an obsession. Their lives are centered around their dogs and they join their national breed clubs and national breed-specific clubs. These people are sometimes referred to as hobby breeders and they compete in performance events and conformation shows.

They’re generally known as preservation or responsible breeders but that doesn’t fully describe their complete dedication.

Lots of people assume good breeders breed puppies for money.

Serious show Pomeranian hobby breeders are not breeding dogs for that reason. It’s purely because they love their chosen dog breed. The amount of money they spend on their dogs far outweighs the amount they would ever get back.

Preservation Reputable Breeder Bred Pomeranian Puppies
Preservation Reputable Breeder Bred Pomeranian Puppies

Don’t be Fooled by the Term “Registered Breeder”

Anyone can easily join the Kennel Club and become a registered breeder. Registered Pomeranian breeders can also be backyard breeders. Would-be Pomeranian puppy owners need to recognize and understand the real difference between show Pomeranian breeders and registered backyard breeders.

The incentives are very high to be a registered breeder: higher prices, easier to advertise and sell kennel club registered pups. Don’t be fooled into purchasing a Pomeranian puppy from a registered backyard Pomeranian breeder.

What is a Backyard Breeder?
What is a Backyard Breeder?

Final Thoughts

Backyard breeders are people who breed their often not pedigree AKC dog with any other dog to produce pups for sale. The parents can be purebreds or even crossbred dogs. Usually, no screening process goes into selecting breeding pairs.

However, the irresponsible breeder may not be aware that this practice is unethical for many reasons, including that it can lead to genetic health problems in offspring.

Copyright Pomeranian.Org. All Rights Reserved.

References and Further Reading:
[1] Official Standard of the Pomeranian (AKC). American Kennel Club, 2011.
[2] Official English Kennel Club Pomeranian Breed Standard, 2017.
[3] Kimbering Pomeranians “1891-1991”.
[4] Denise Leo, The Pomeranian Handbook.


Denise Leo

Pomeranians are my passion, and I have shared my life with these darling little dogs for many decades. The creator and face behind this website is published author and Pomeranian breed authority Denise Leo of Dochlaggie Pomeranians.

Denise Leo
Denise Leo